What Is Uncanny Valley?

Do you ever feel uneasy when encountering lifelike robots or computer-generated characters that are almost human but not quite? That unsettling sensation is known as the Uncanny Valley.

In this article, we’ll explore the origins of the Uncanny Valley, provide examples of it in action, delve into what causes this eerie effect, and examine the research surrounding it.

You’ll also discover its implications and learn how to avoid falling into this uncanny pit.

So let’s dive in and unravel the mysteries of the Uncanny Valley together!

Origins of Uncanny Valley

The origins of the uncanny valley can be traced back to the Japanese roboticist Masahiro Mori in 1970. In his work, Mori observed that people found his robots more appealing as they looked more human, but only up to a certain point. Once the robots appeared close but not quite human, people started feeling uncomfortable or even disgusted. This phenomenon was termed bukimi no tani genshō or ‘valley of eeriness’ by Mori.

The term ‘uncanny valley’ was later translated by author Jasia Reichardt in 1978. According to Mori’s seminal paper on the topic, he explained that as robots climb towards resembling humans, our affinity for them increases until we reach a valley where feelings of unease and disturbance arise. Examples such as industrial robots lacking human likeness and prosthetic hands lying in this uncanny valley were provided by Mori to illustrate his idea.

Uncanny Valley Examples

When it comes to examples of the uncanny valley, three key points that stand out are cats, Shrek, and Final Fantasy.

1. Cats

Despite mixed reactions, viewers found the humanoid felines in Cats to be unsettling and nightmare-inducing. The use of CGI technology in the film aimed to bring these characters to life, but instead it seemed to fall into what experts call the ‘uncanny valley.’

This phenomenon occurs when a human-like object or character looks almost real, but not quite, causing a sense of unease and revulsion in the viewer. In the case of Cats, the realistic fur textures combined with human facial features created an eerie effect that many found off-putting.

The uncanny valley concept has been studied by researchers for years and is often used as a cautionary tale when designing robots or digital avatars. It serves as a reminder that achieving true realism can sometimes have unintended consequences.

• The humanoid felines in Cats had realistic fur textures and human facial features.
• The combination of these elements created an eerie effect.
• Many viewers described the characters as unsettling and nightmare-inducing.

2. Shrek

You might be surprised to know that early test screenings of Shrek caused anxiety in children due to Princess Fiona’s lifelike appearance. Kids were unnerved and even frightened by her realistic features, often crying whenever she appeared onscreen. This reaction can be attributed to a phenomenon known as the uncanny valley.

The uncanny valley refers to the uneasy feeling people experience when they encounter something that is almost but not quite human-like. In the case of Princess Fiona, her lifelike appearance fell into this unsettling territory for many children. The animators behind Shrek recognized this issue and made adjustments to her character design before the film’s release, giving her a more cartoon-like appearance.

3. Final Fantasy

If you were a fan of Final Fantasy, you might have been impressed by the movie’s groundbreaking CGI animation. Released in 2001, Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within showcased some of the most realistic computer-generated characters ever seen at that time. The film aimed to push the boundaries of what was possible with CGI technology and create lifelike human characters.

However, despite its technical achievements, the movie was a commercial failure. Many attribute this failure to a phenomenon known as the uncanny valley. This refers to the discomfort people feel when encountering artificial beings that closely resemble humans but still fall short in terms of realism.

In the case of Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within, audiences found the animation disturbing and unsettling, which likely contributed to its lackluster performance at the box office.

What Causes the Uncanny Valley Effect?

When it comes to understanding why the uncanny valley effect occurs, there are several key factors at play.

1. Ambiguity

The sensation of being ‘creeped out’ is often caused by a sense of ambiguity, creating a tension that feels unpleasant. When we encounter something that is almost but not quite human, it can elicit this unsettling feeling. This effect is known as the uncanny valley.

Ambiguity plays a crucial role in triggering this response because our brains struggle to categorize these ambiguous stimuli as either human or non-human. Research suggests that our brains have evolved to quickly and efficiently recognize familiar patterns and faces. When faced with an ambiguous stimulus, such as a doll or a clown with exaggerated features, our brain’s recognition system becomes confused, leading to feelings of discomfort and unease.

Understanding the role of ambiguity in the uncanny valley phenomenon can help explain why certain images or characters evoke such strong emotional responses.

2. Inconsistency

Inconsistency is another key factor that contributes to the uncanny valley phenomenon. As mentioned earlier, even the smallest inconsistencies in a robotic or animated humanoid can make it appear less lifelike and more unsettling to humans. For example, Mori’s original experiment showed that a robotic character became creepy when its smile was slightly too slow.

To further understand how inconsistency affects our perception of human-like characters, consider the following:

• Movement: If a robot’s movements are not fluid or coordinated, it can create an uneasy feeling in observers.
• Facial Expressions: Inaccurate or unnatural facial expressions can also contribute to the sense of unease.
• Voice and Speech: Robotic voices or speech patterns that sound artificial can be jarring and disconnect us from perceiving them as human.

3. Survival Response

Our survival response to human-like but not quite lifelike beings may be triggered by the potential threats of death and disease. When we encounter something that is almost lifelike, but not quite there, it can create a sense of unease and discomfort within us.

This response is believed to be rooted in our evolutionary past, where our ancestors needed to quickly identify potential dangers in order to survive. The uncanny valley phenomenon can be seen as an extension of this survival response.

As humans, we are wired to detect signs of illness or death in others, as these could pose a threat to our own well-being. Therefore, when faced with beings that resemble humans but lack the vitality of life, it triggers a primordial instinct within us that warns us of potential danger.

4. Mismatched Elements

When you encounter beings that combine elements that don’t normally go together, it can create a sense of unease and discomfort within you. This phenomenon is known as the uncanny valley. Research has shown that people tend to be disturbed by these mismatched elements, whether they are found in robots or computer animations featuring people and animals.

Here are three examples of mismatched elements that can trigger the uncanny valley effect:

1) A robot with a human-like face but mechanical movements. The combination of familiar facial features with unnatural motions can be unsettling.

2) An animated character with realistic textures and details, but exaggerated proportions. This juxtaposition of hyper-realism and distortion can create a feeling of uneasiness.

3) A virtual assistant with a voice that sounds almost human, but lacking natural intonations and emotions. This discordance between appearance and behavior can elicit discomfort.

Understanding the impact of mismatched elements on our perception is crucial in designing more relatable and appealing beings in fields such as robotics and animation.

5. Category Uncertainty

If you’re unsure about which category an entity belongs to, such as whether it’s a real human or a computer-generated model, it can create a sense of unease and discomfort. Theories suggest that the uncanny valley phenomenon arises from the difficulty in determining what category an entity falls into. It occurs when something appears to transition between being human and nonhuman, triggering feelings of cognitive dissonance.

This conflict between beliefs can lead to psychological discomfort. When an artificial representation looks almost alive but lacks certain realistic elements, it clashes with our expectations of how a real person would behave. This mismatch between what we see and what we expect can leave us feeling ambivalent or even threatened.

Category uncertainty plays a significant role in generating the creepy feeling associated with the uncanny valley effect.

Research on the Uncanny Valley

When it comes to the uncanny valley, there are several key points that researchers have explored.

Likeness and Eeriness

You might feel a sense of eeriness when you encounter something that closely resembles a human but is not quite there. This feeling of unease is known as the uncanny valley, a term coined by robotics professor Masahiro Mori in 1970.

In a study conducted in 2013, researchers explored the relationship between human-likeness and eeriness and found evidence supporting the existence of the uncanny valley. The study focused on manipulating facial proportions and realism to determine their impact on perceptions of eeriness.

The results showed a linear relationship between likeness and eeriness, suggesting that as an artificial entity becomes more human-like, it can elicit stronger feelings of unease. Understanding this phenomenon is crucial for designers and developers working with humanoid robots or virtual characters to create experiences that do not trigger discomfort in users.

Children’s Responses

Children may experience feelings of unease when they encounter virtual characters that lack upper facial expression or startled facial expressions. This is because these features play a crucial role in human communication and emotional understanding. Research has shown that children between the ages of 9 and 11 are particularly susceptible to these feelings of uncanniness when interacting with human-like virtual characters.

Here are some key points about children’s responses to virtual characters:

• Lack of upper facial expression can make virtual characters seem strange and less friendly.
• Startled facial expressions are more likely to be perceived as uncanny by children.
• Children may feel uncomfortable or uneasy when faced with virtual characters that do not display normal facial expressions.
• These negative reactions can impact their overall perception and engagement with the virtual environment.
• Understanding how children respond to different facial expressions in virtual characters is important for designing more realistic and relatable experiences for them.

Other Names

If you want to learn more about the phenomenon of discomfort with realistic virtual characters, it might be helpful to explore the various names that researchers have given it.

One such name is ‘the uncanny valley.’ This term was coined by Japanese roboticist Masahiro Mori in 1970 and refers to the eerie feeling people experience when interacting with robots or animated characters that are almost but not quite human-like.

The concept suggests that as a robot’s appearance becomes increasingly realistic, there is a point where humans start to feel uneasy or even repulsed by it.

Other names for this phenomenon include ‘Mori’s Hypothesis,’ ‘Mori’s Uncanny Valley,’ and ‘Uncanniness.’ Understanding these different names can provide insight into the extensive research conducted on this subject and help us delve deeper into our discomfort with realistic virtual characters.

Can It Be Prevented?

To avoid the eerie feeling associated with interacting with almost human-like robots or animated characters, it’s important to focus on good design and aesthetics.

Research has shown that poor design and aesthetics can contribute to the uncanny valley phenomenon, where people experience a sense of unease or discomfort. According to a scientific investigation conducted in 2005, this eerie feeling can be overcome by implementing good design principles.

By paying attention to details such as facial expressions, body movements, and overall appearance, designers can create more realistic and appealing humanoid robots or animated characters. This means considering factors like symmetry, proportionality, and lifelike features when designing these entities.

When done well, good design can bridge the gap between realism and artificiality, reducing the likelihood of experiencing the uncanny valley effect.

Implications of the Uncanny Valley

In the fields of film, robotics, game design, and digital avatars, the concept of the uncanny valley holds significant importance.

When it comes to film, filmmakers strive to create realistic characters that evoke emotions from the audience. However, if a character falls into the uncanny valley where it appears almost human but not quite, it can result in an unsettling response from viewers.

Similarly, in robotics and game design, creating human-like robots or characters can enhance engagement and interaction but crossing into the uncanny valley can have negative effects on user experience.

1. Film

Despite the use of CGI effects in blockbuster films, filmmakers are still striving to create computer-generated animations that blend seamlessly and avoid the uncanny valley.

The uncanny valley refers to a phenomenon where human-like characters or animations that are almost but not quite realistic can cause feelings of unease or revulsion in viewers. This is because our brains are wired to recognize subtle cues and discrepancies in human appearance and behavior.

When these cues are not accurately replicated in CGI characters, it can create a sense of discomfort. Filmmakers understand this challenge and work hard to strike a balance between realism and stylization in their animated films.

2. Robotics

In the field of robotics, the concept of the uncanny valley is crucial. It refers to the discomfort or uneasiness that people feel when they encounter robots or robotic technology that closely resembles humans but falls short in some way.

This phenomenon has significant implications for the development and acceptance of assistive technologies for individuals with disabilities. To ensure that these devices are well-received and effectively utilized, designers must strike a delicate balance between usefulness and aesthetic appeal.

Creating robots that are too human-like but still not quite there can lead to a negative response from users. Therefore, it is essential to carefully consider design elements such as facial features, movements, and overall appearance to avoid triggering feelings of unease or distrust.

3. Game Design

When playing video games, you may notice how realistic characters can evoke different emotions and reactions from you. Game designers often aim to create characters that are believable and lifelike, but there is a fine line between realism and the uncanny valley.

The uncanny valley refers to the phenomenon where humanoid characters that are almost but not quite human-like elicit feelings of unease or discomfort in viewers. This can be particularly impactful in game design, as players become emotionally invested in the virtual world.

Designers may intentionally use the uncanny valley to their advantage by creating villainous characters that evoke a sense of dyspathy or repulsion from players. By understanding and leveraging this concept, game designers can enhance the immersive experience for players and add depth to their narratives.

4. Digital Avatars

Now let’s delve into the world of digital avatars.

In online therapy, therapists and clients often rely on these representations to facilitate communication through mediums like chat or email. However, it’s essential to strike a balance when it comes to their appearance.

Research has shown that overly realistic avatars can sometimes hinder the therapeutic process. Take, for instance, robots designed to resemble humans too closely. One study discovered that participants found these human-like robots less likable and trustworthy compared to those with more distinct robotic features. This poses a significant challenge in a therapeutic context since trust plays a vital role in treatment success.

Therefore, finding the right balance in designing digital avatars is crucial. They must be visually appealing without crossing into the uncanny valley – that eerie feeling we experience when an artificial being appears almost human but not quite right.

Criticisms of the Uncanny Valley

Understanding these factors can help researchers and designers navigate the challenges posed by the uncanny valley phenomenon.

Age May Play a Role

Age may indeed play a role in determining if individuals experience the uncanny valley phenomenon. Research suggests that older generations are more likely to be affected by the uncanny valley, while younger people who have grown up with advanced technology may be less susceptible to it.

Here are three reasons why age might influence one’s experience of the uncanny valley:

1. Familiarity: Younger individuals who have been exposed to robotics and CGI effects from an early age are more accustomed to seeing human-like entities that fall within the realm of ‘almost human.’ This familiarity could make them less likely to perceive these entities as eerie or unsettling.
2. Cognitive Development: As people age, their cognitive abilities evolve, including their ability to distinguish between real and simulated appearances. Older individuals may have a harder time discerning artificial beings from real humans, leading them to experience discomfort in the presence of lifelike but not-quite-human entities.
3. Emotional Response: Age-related changes in emotional processing may also contribute to differing reactions towards the uncanny valley phenomenon. Older adults might be more prone to experiencing negative emotions when encountering humanoid figures that deviate slightly from human appearance due to factors such as reduced flexibility in adapting their emotional responses.

Further research is needed to fully understand how age influences individual experiences of the uncanny valley phenomenon.

The Effect Is Highly Varied

You may find it interesting that the effect of the phenomenon can vary greatly in different situations and for different senses.

The uncanny valley, which refers to the discomfort or unease experienced when interacting with human-like entities, is not a one-size-fits-all experience. Research has shown that the extent to which individuals perceive this effect can be influenced by various factors.

For instance, some studies have found that certain facial features or expressions can trigger stronger feelings of unease than others. Additionally, the context in which an artificial entity is presented can also play a role. For example, a humanoid robot may evoke different responses depending on whether it is encountered in a controlled laboratory setting or in a real-world environment.

These variations highlight the complexity and multidimensionality of the uncanny valley phenomenon, emphasizing its nuanced nature and its potential to elicit different reactions from individuals across diverse situations and senses.

Avoiding the Uncanny Valley

Creating robotic devices that do not mimic human appearance may be a more appealing approach to avoid the uncanny valley. By opting for a non-human design, these devices can still fulfill their purpose without causing discomfort or revulsion in users.

Researchers and designers have proposed various design principles to achieve this, such as matching realistic textures with human proportions and avoiding a mix of nonhuman and human elements. It is crucial to ensure that behaviors, appearance, and abilities do not conflict with each other.

In an interview with Wired, Mori suggests stopping before reaching the point of uncanniness rather than trying to bridge the uncanny valley. This approach allows for the creation of tools or devices that are likable and comfortable for users without evoking unsettling feelings.

A Word From UMOM

There hasn’t been much research on the uncanny valley phenomenon yet. However, as time goes on, more information about why it happens and ways to overcome it will surely emerge. According to Mori himself, his original observation was meant to be a guideline for designers rather than a scientific statement.

As technology keeps advancing, it’s possible that robots and digital animations could become so realistic that they seamlessly blend with reality. This would eliminate discomfort or anxiety for people. In the meantime, robots, digital avatars, and online animations are becoming increasingly common in everyday life. Therefore, it’s important for designers to consider the emotional response of their audience.

The Bottom Line

The concept of the Uncanny Valley is a fascinating phenomenon that has been studied extensively in the field of robotics and animation. It refers to the discomfort experienced by humans when they encounter humanoid entities that are almost but not quite human-like.

This effect can have significant implications for various industries, including entertainment, healthcare, and even military applications. While there are criticisms surrounding the theory, researchers continue to explore ways to avoid triggering the Uncanny Valley response through careful design and understanding of human perception.

Frequently Asked Questions